The Gardiner Cup results were researched and compiled by John Punshon and written by Greg Stock.

Source various New South Wales newspapers and Bill Walker.

FIRST ROUND Balmain Kia-Ora, Cessnock, Pyrmont, Wallsend, Weston United - Bye
Saturday July 13 1918 Epping Racecourse, Glebe Referee: Bill Lincoln
Young Mens Christian Association Lineup Included; V.Paling, Berchdolt, Burns, Richmond, R.Neilson, L.Forrester, D.Neilson, Whitehead, L.Sheffield. Goal: Sheffield	1	-	1	Canterbury Lineup Included; Willgate, Bannister, D.Herron, Fryer, Jim Herron, McAdam, Shipley, Williams, Mackie, Ward. Goal: Ward
Saturday July 13 1918 Epping Racecourse, Glebe Referee: A.E.Kay
Annandale Lineup Included; George Cartwright, Keith, Williams, McAllister, W.Carroll, A.Doerner, Smith, Bond, Chalmers. Goal: Storey	1	-	0	Balmain Fernleigh Hughes, Hancock, Batten, Leadbeater, Ferguson, Storey, Voges, Bob Matthews, Porter, Roy Matthews, F,Yabsley.
Saturday July 13 1918 Newcastle Showground Referee: A.E.Court
Adamstown-Merewether Advance Bob Elgey, Williams, Stewart, Myers, F.Hayes, J.Sneddon, Sneddon, John Doyle, F.Watson, Thorpe, Tolhurst. Goals: Hayes (x2 pens), Watson	3	-	4	Young Wallsend-West Wallsend Brooks, N.Convery, Lee, Anderson, Hodge, Coutts, L.Gardiner, Ted Coates, Johnson, Kaiser, Arthur Gardiner. Goals: Kaiser (x2), Johnson (x2)

FIRST ROUND REPLAY
Saturday July 20 1918 Epping Racecourse, Glebe
Young Mens Christian Association Lineup Included; Green, L.Forrester, D.Neilson, Whitehead, R.Neilson. Goals: Green (x2), Forrester, D.Neilson, Whitehead, R.Neilson	6	-	0	Canterbury (Lineup Not Known)

SECOND ROUND
Saturday August 3 1918 Epping Racecourse, Glebe
Pyrmont Lineup Included; Doodson, S.Robinson, S.Anderson, J.Gray, Kelso, Mahon, Sid Blake, Wally Moore, J.Sherringham, A.McLean. Goals: Moore, Sherringham	2	-	2	Annandale George Cartwright, Keith, Williams (Lind), Chalmers, Smith, McAllister, Storey, D.Bond, A.Doerner, W.Carroll, Towle. Goals: Carroll, Towle
Saturday August 3 1918 Sydney Cricket Ground No 2
Balmain Kia-Ora Lineup Included; A.Cornwall, O.White, Eddie Ferrier, A.Creighton, C.Henson, A.Forbes. Goals: Henson (x5), Forbes	6	-	0	Young Mens Christian Association Lineup Included; Green, Whitehead.
Saturday August 10 1918 Homestead Ground, Weston
Cessnock Lineup Included; Harold, Thompson, Muir, Strang, Rennix, Hancock. Goal: Hancock	1	-	0	Young Wallsend-West Wallsend Lineup Included; Coutts, Lee, Laverty, Bill Maunder, Arthur Gardiner, Ted Coates.
Saturday August 10 1918 Newcastle Showground Referee: W.Stott Match ordered to be replayed due to irregularities in the lineups
Wallsend W.Rushton, Davies, Bob Lidbury, Ted Mahoney, T.Lidbury, W.Mahoney, Bower, H.Gray, Charlie Roy, Bert Mamafield, Albert Morgan.	0	-	1	Weston United Bob Austin, Bill Lambert, J.Henry, J.Duxfield, H.Hollingworth, Dick Austin, W.Beverley, Len Pugh, Jack Avis, H.Bellamy, Jim Bellamy. Goal: J.Bellamy

SECOND ROUND REPLAYS
Saturday August 10 1918 Epping Racecourse, Glebe
Annandale George Cartwright, Keith, Williams, Chalmers, Smith, McAllister, Storey, D.Bond, A.Doerner, Johnston, Towle. Goal: Doerner pen	1	-	2	Pyrmont Lineup Included; Doodson, S.Anderson, S.Robinson, H.Robinson, Kelso, Wally Moore, J.Sherringham, R.Maitland. Goals: Anderson pen, Maitland
Saturday August 31 1918 Newcastle Showground Referee: A.E.Court After Extra Time
Wallsend W.Rushton, Davies, Bob Lidbury, Ted Mahoney, T.Lidbury, Albert Morgan, Bert Mamafield, H.Gray, Charles, Shaw, Bower. Goal: Mahoney	1	-	1	Weston United Bob Austin, Henry, Bill Lambert, J.Duxfield, H.Hollingworth, Shields, Beverley, H.Bellamy, Jack Avis, Len Pugh (Jim Bellamy), A.McNaughton. Goal: Bellamy

SECOND ROUND SECOND REPLAY
Saturday September 7 1918 Homestead Ground, Weston Referee: F.Jennings
Weston United Bob Austin, Bill Lambert, J.Henry, J.Duxfield, H.Hollingworth, Dick Austin, W.Beverley, Len Pugh, Jack Avis, A.McNaughton, H.Bellamy. Goals: Austin pen, Bellamy, Pugh, Avis (x2)	5	-	0	Wallsend Lineup Included; W.Rushton, Lidbury, Davies, Ted Mahoney, T.Lidbury, Albert Morgan, Bower, Shaw, H.Gray, Roy. Sent Off: Davies, Gray

SEMI-FINALS
Saturday August 31 1918 Epping Racecourse, Glebe Referee: Bill Lincoln After Extra Time
Balmain Kia-Ora A.Cornwall, G.Smart, W.Leckie, A.Creighton, Eddie Ferrier, O.White, Dick Miranda, A.Craig, C.Henson, A.Forbes, J.Heyman. Goal: Forbes	1	-	1	Pyrmont Doodson, S.Anderson, S.Robinson, McMahon, Kelso, H.Robinson, Sid Blake, J.Sherringham, Johnson, R.Maitland, A.McLean. Goal: Maitland
Saturday September 14 1918 Homestead Ground, Weston Referee: F.Jennings
Weston United Lineup Included; Bob Austin. Goals: (Goalscorers Not Known)	2	-	1	Cessnock (Lineup and Goalscorer Not Known)

SEMI-FINAL REPLAY
Saturday September 7 1918 Epping Racecourse, Glebe Referee: Bill Lincoln After Extra Time
Balmain Kia-Ora A.Cornwall, W.Leckie, Law, A.Creighton, Eddie Ferrier, O.White, A.Craig, A.Lyons, C.Henson, A.Forbes, J.Heyman. Goals: Forbes (x2), Heyman	3	-	3	Pyrmont Doodson, S.Anderson, S.Robinson, McMahon, Kelso, H.Robinson, Sid Blake, J.Sherringham, Wally Moore, R.Maitland, A.McLean. Goals: Sherringham, Moore, Anderson pen

SEMI-FINAL SECOND REPLAY
Saturday September 14 1918 Epping Racecourse, Glebe
Balmain Kia-Ora A.Cornwall, G.Smart, W.Leckie, A.Creighton, EddieFerrier, O.White, A.Craig, A.Lyons, C.Henson, A.Forbes, Dick Miranda. Goals: Craig, Henson (x2), Lyons	4	-	1	Pyrmont Doodson, S.Anderson, S.Robinson, H.Robinson, Kelso, McMahon, Sid Blake, J.Sherringham, Wally Moore, R.Maitland, A.McLean. Goal: Anderson pen

---

1918 GARDINER CUP FINAL
Saturday September 21 1918 Epping Racecourse, Glebe Referee: A.E.Kay
Balmain Kia-Ora A.Cornwall, G.Smart, W.Leckie, A.Creighton, Eddie Ferrier, O.White, A.Craig, C.Henson, A.Lyons, A.Forbes, Dick Miranda.	0	-	1	Weston United Bob Austin, Bill Lambert, J.Henry, Dick Austin, H.Hollingworth, J.Duxfield, W.Beverley, Len Pugh, Jack Avis, A.McNaughton, Jim Bellamy. Goal: Duxfield